Why Massage Works Differently for Different People

The same massage can do wonders for one person and very little for the next. That isn’t about who tried harder. Bodies are built differently, and what settles one can stir up another. Ayurveda gave me a simple language for this, though my hands had been feeling it for years before I had the words. This post is about how it shows up on the table, and why the advice that works for everyone else may not have worked for you.

Years ago I did an online test to find my type in Ayurveda. It said I was the light, quick type. So I followed the advice for that type, carefully, and I got more stuck in my head, more stressed and more anxious.

Then I saw an Ayurvedic physician, and he told me the opposite. I’m the heavy, steady build, with a fair bit of fire in it. The two are opposite ends of the scale. What I’d actually had was an imbalance of the light, quick kind, which is very common in big-city life, and it had fooled the test. What I really needed was to get out of my head and move my body, regularly.

The advice wasn’t bad. It was written for a different body. And I see the same thing on the table often: two people with the same complaint, the same work, and completely different results.

Why doesn’t the same massage work the same on everyone?

Because no two bodies are the same, not even twins. In Ayurveda, the traditional medicine of India, everything, the body included, is made of five elements: space, air, fire, water and earth. Each of us has a different mix. Where air and space lead, a person tends to be light and quick; Ayurveda calls this Vata. Where fire leads, they’re warm and driven: Pitta. Where earth and water lead, they’re heavy and steady: Kapha. Most people are a mix of two.

I’m not an Ayurvedic practitioner, and I never use this to diagnose anyone. It’s one lens, one slice of the cake. To be honest, most of the time I just feel these things in the moment and respond. But the lens helps.

You can feel it under your hands. The light, quick types are often the very slim people, the ones who can eat loads and never put on much muscle. They usually need less pressure; sometimes I can’t even use my elbow without hitting a bone. Their hands and feet are often cold. The heavy, steady types, like me, are denser. They usually need more pressure and deeper work just to get through those layers. The warm, driven ones sit somewhere in between. I can feel their muscles easily and the work flows. They often want to know exactly what I’m doing and why.

But the build only gives a general idea. What really decides the pressure is what I feel that day, and how your body answers.

When I first found out my type, I didn’t want it. Heavy and slow? Who wants that? But in the end it was so liberating. It felt like permission to be myself, and to stop fighting my own nature.

That test taught me the difference between my build and the state I was in. A heavy, steady body can still be scattered and anxious after a hard month. The seasons play a part, too. I’m one of the cold-weather strugglers; I used to tell people I’d rather sweat than freeze. Sometimes I ask clients whether they prefer summer or winter, because the answer often says something about their type. The same person needs different things in February and in August, and again after an injury, a bad run of sleep or a hard year at work.

Why hasn’t the popular advice worked for me?

My impression from the table, and it’s only an impression, not a statistic, is that a lot of the advice that gets shouted loudest really does work, for maybe twenty people in a hundred. Those twenty are the ones on the podcasts and in the videos, and they’re convincing, because it worked for them.

So the other eighty try it. It doesn’t work. And the first place most of us look is ourselves: what’s wrong with me? Why can’t I do what they do?

I know that voice well; it’s been in my own head plenty of times. I see it on the table, too. A woman I’ve worked with for a long time tried yoga, then one kind after another, and most of them left her tighter than before. In the end she found out most styles simply didn’t suit her type. Another client works in a world where how you look is part of the job. She was doing everything the popular health advice says, and from the outside it showed. Under my hands, though, her muscles felt like steel cables, as if her whole body was working to hold everything together.

So let me tell you what I wish someone had told me back then. There’s nothing wrong with you if the general answer hasn’t worked. You’re not a failed version of someone else’s method. And no, knowing your build isn’t an excuse to do less. It tells you which effort is yours. My body is heavy and steady, so it needs more movement, not less.

One thing to watch out for: we’re often drawn to exactly the advice that makes our imbalance worse. If you’re driven, the tougher regime sounds exciting. If you’re restless, the newest thing does. If a piece of advice sounds a bit too good to you, it’s worth a second look.

What can you do with this?

If each build could ask for one thing, I think it would be something like this. The light, quick body: warm me, ground me, slow me down. The heavy, steady one: move me, wake me up. The warm, driven one: cool me, take the pressure off. That’s roughly how I adjust a session, too: the pressure, the pace, how much we talk, where I start.

You don’t need a quiz to begin. For one week, track only this: what gave you energy today, and what took it? Not what you ate, not how you exercised. Just what lifted you and what drained you. The pattern will tell you more than any system can.

When I track mine, a lot of it comes down to space. I can be social, and sometimes I need people around me to get my energy going. But other times I need to close the world out for a while: no work, nobody else, just me and my thoughts. What helps me most is a walk in nature, or a few minutes on my own in a café. That’s how I get back to neutral.

There’s a line I first heard through Ayurveda that sums all of this up: what’s a cure for one can be poison for another.

A build is a way of looking at yourself, not a label, and none of this is a diagnosis. If something feels wrong, see your doctor.

I can’t tell you from a page which build you are, or what your body needs. What I can do is feel it, work with it, and help you notice it for yourself.

And if you’re wondering how much pressure your body actually needs, I’ve written about that in Deep Tissue Massage: Why Harder Pressure Isn’t Always Better.

I’m Mihaly (pronounced [ˈmiha:j]), an intuitive bodywork practitioner. Born in Hungary, living in London these days. I’ve been doing this work since 2010, helping people let go of the tension and stress their bodies have been holding. If that sounds like what you need, you can book a session below.

More Reflections:

How the Work Deepens

When we begin working together, the first sessions often feel like deep tissue work, because that’s what years of built-up tension needs first. That’s the first wave: relief. But something else is happening underneath it: your body is starting to recognise its own patterns, sometimes for the first time.

Then the pattern itself starts to shift. As your body gets used to the work, deeper layers open up, and tension that’s been there so long you stopped noticing it begins to move. This happens gradually, not in one dramatic session.

And eventually the new way becomes your normal. Clients often describe carrying less: less tension, less reactivity. That’s when the work moves from getting you back to keeping you there, and the sessions take on a different quality.

Introductory Session

For New Clients

Your first session is about discovery, for both of us. We’ll start with a short conversation, 5 to 15 minutes, so I understand what’s brought you here and what your body has been carrying. Then we move into hands-on work, and I let what I find there guide us rather than following a fixed routine. Most people are surprised by where the tension actually lives: it’s rarely only where it hurts.

Returning Clients

Follow-up sessions have a different quality. Your body already knows what this work feels like, which means it tends to drop into release faster and deeper. We go further with less effort, and that’s when the more persistent patterns start to shift.

Foundation Package

3-Session Series

For when you’re just starting. The body is often slow to notice change, so at the beginning, sessions work best close together, ideally within a few weeks. Three sessions give your body time to get used to the work, and give us both a clearer picture of what’s really going on.

Special Offer

Get 5 for the price of 4

For when you’ve felt a change and want to keep it going. Five sessions, spaced however suits you, let the work build instead of starting over each time, and one of them is on me.